which is better landscape fabric or plastic
When it comes to gardening, choosing between landscape fabric and plastic sheeting has its distinct differences. Here are some key points to consider:
Breathability: Landscape fabric allows for air circulation, promoting healthier plants, while plastic sheeting creates a barrier that can lead to heat and moisture buildup.
Longevity: High-quality landscape fabric, when properly installed and maintained, can last several years, whereas plastic sheeting degrades faster due to UV exposure and typically requires annual replacement.
Weed Control: Both landscape fabric and plastic sheeting initially block weeds, but fabric is less prone to developing tears over time that allow weeds to reestablish. Plastic is more susceptible to tearing.
Cost: Landscape fabric has a higher upfront cost but proves cost-effective in the long run due to its durability and reduced need for frequent replacement compared to plastic sheeting.
Aesthetics: Landscape fabric blends better into landscapes, appearing less noticeable when camouflaged with mulch or soil. Plastic sheeting, on the other hand, can look unnatural and is harder to hide.
Earthworms/Beneficials: Landscape fabric allows the passage of earthworms and other beneficial soil organisms, while plastic can disrupt their activity.
Installation: Fabric is easier to install in existing landscapes without disturbing plants or soil structure, as opposed to removing and reinstalling plastic sheeting.
In conclusion, landscape fabric provides reliable and long-lasting weed control, thanks to its breathability, durability, and minimal impact on soil and plant health over multiple growing seasons. Regular inspection and repair of tears are essential for both materials. Consider your specific gardening needs and conditions to make an informed choice between landscape fabric and plastic sheeting.
